Rico Bron dissects the 2025 Mets’ position players with a brutal, fantasy-focused lens. Luis Torrens earns an A- for elite defense and handling of the staff, while Francisco Alvarez plates a strong second half after a midseason trip to the minors. Brett Batty and Brandon Nimmo provide solid contributions, Pete Alonso and Francisco Lindor deliver steady if not explosive seasons, and the rest struggle with injuries and inconsistent playing time. Jose Siri, Cedric Mullins, and Jose Azocar are graded harshly for underperformance, while the center-field carousel and missed opportunities loom large in the narrative of a disappointing campaign.

The Mets face a pivotal offseason: balance defense and offense without gutting a potent core. Nimmo could be a payroll lever, while Lindor's sometimes shaky defense creates a trade/position-change debate. Alonso and Soto anchor the lineup, with internal options like Vientos and McNeil in the fringe. The plan centers on improving run prevention and defensive leverage rather than an all-out rebuild.

The path forward aims to keep Alonso-Soto intact, shore up the infield defense, and possibly deploy a defensive DH. Expect gradual roster reshaping—moving a core piece or two if it unlocks defensive upgrades—while preserving enough offense to contend in 2025.